Saturday, November 7, 2009

في انتظار سيادة المحافظ




العمل في مجال العشوائيات ليس بالشئ السهل علي الاطلاق، فقد تضطر احيانا الي السفر خارج القاهرة و الذهاب الي احدي الاقليم لالتقاط صورة واحدة لوضع ما، ثم تعود و انت في قمة سعادتك... فما بالك لو انه مؤتمر و ورشة عمل و جولة في منطقة عشوائية...؟ و قد كان هذا الوضع تماما، يوم اتصلت بي الدكتورة دينا شهيب (مثلي الاعلي في مجال العمل بالعشوئيات و مشرفة رسالة الماجستير الخاصة بي) يوم الاربعاء و اعلمتني بانه سيقام مؤتمر و ورشة عمل في مدينة الاسماعيلية يوم الخميس و سوف يحضره السيد المحافظ لمناقشة وضع المناطق العشوائية في الاسماعيلية و التنسيق مع الجهات المختلفة كالمجالس المحلية و الجمعيات الاهليه و من هم مثلي من الباحثين المعماريين الاجتماعيين... بالطبع امتلئني الحماس حيث ان الوضع لن يكون التقاط صورة و السلاموا عليكوا، بل سيكون صور و مؤتمر و ورشة عمل و مقابلة السيد المحافظ.

اويت الي الفراش هذه الليلة و بدأت في ترتيب افكاري التي سأطرحها غدا في المؤتمر، حتي غلبني النعاس محتضن افكاري كطفل يحتضن حذائة الجديد ليلة العيد.

استيقظت باكر الخميس باحساس غريب، و كأن اليوم يومي، و كأن يومي كاحد ايام صديقي الكاتب محمد المعتصم في وصف احد ايامة (http://almodawana.wordpress.com/)، و الذي سأحاول ان اصف مثله كيف كان يومي رائع... فكما قلت، استيقظت باكر الخميس حوالي الساعة 5:30 ص، مستشعرا اهمية اليوم و لا استطيع الانتظار (فانا احب عملي الي حد الهوس)، مستقبلا جو رائع، ربيعي يتخلله لمسة سقيع، افطار لطيف خفيف، ارتدي ملابسي المفضلة، اعداد اوراقي، و نزلت من البيت... الجو يزداد جمالا – او انا فقط من يشعر بذلك – ركبت سيارة اختي لأن بها كاسيت و انطلقت مستمعا الي موسيقتي المفضلة... رائع طريق الاسماعيلية صباحا، يفجر حنين ما لا استطيع ان اتعرف تماما حنين الي ماذا، و لكن الشعور موجود. ابدأ في الاقتراب من مدينة الاسماعيلية و يستقبلني مدخلها الرائع من غابات الاشجار، ما هذه المدينة؟ انها رائعة الجمال. اخرجت الكاميرا و بدأت اصور كل ما حولي، حتي انني اصبت بذهول حينما كنت استرجع الصور علي الكاميرا و استوقفتني صورة، اعتقدت انها لوس انجلوس. فقلت " الله يمسيك بالخير يا عبد المنعم يا عمارة" فهو محافظ الاسماعيلية السابق و صاحب الفضل في تحويلها الي تلك الجنه صغيرة.




وصلت اخيرا الي فندق ميركور الذي سيقام فيه المؤتمر، مبني الفندق هو مبني علي طراز عمارة ما بعد الثورة مطعما بلمسة اسلامية. لفت نظري عند دخولي المبني النجف في السقف، حيث ان كل نجفة تستوعب حوالي عشرين لمبة، و لكن ادارة الفندق استعاضت العشرين لمبة بلمبة واحدة فلوريسنت ابيض في كل نجفة، فسألت نفسي، لماذا ابيض؟ من امؤكد انه سيكون قبيحا جدا ليلا. دخلت القاعة التي سيقوم بها المؤتمر حيث استقبلني الدكتور خالد عبد الحليم - ايضا من اكفا العاملين بمجال العشوائيات في مصر – و قام بتعريفي علي الحاضرين و تعريف الحاضرين بي، و قال لي: نحن في انتظار سيادة المحافظ...

القاعة المقام بها المؤتمر ليست بالكبيرة، تتوسطها ترابيزة طويلة، يلتف حولها حوالي خمسين كرسي، يجلس علي تلك الكراسي مجموعات من الحاضرين. لفت نظري الحاضرين، حيث انهم منقسمون الي مجموعات متفرقة. فكانت هناك مجموعة من مرتديين البدل في سن الخمسين و من الواضح انهم مديرين مصالح ما، و نساء بدون كموظفين المصالح من بتوع " يا استاذ، ورقك ناقص" و " تعالى بكرة تاني" و "انت هتعلمني شغلي ولا ايه؟". و مجموعة اخري من النسخة الرجالي من اولائك الموظفات. و رجل يتحدث بالفصحة طوال الوقت و الأخرون من المهندسون المعماريون و الاجتماعيون و حفنة رجال لا اعرف سبب وجودهم، فهم نائمون من قبل ان يبدأ المؤتمر...

دخل رجل القاعة مبلغا الحاضرين بوصول سيارة السيد المحافظ، فانطلقت سيدة من مكانها تطلب من الدكتور خالد ان يقوم باستقبالة قائلة: " قوم يا دكتور استقبل السيد المحافظ... يييه... انت مش لابس بدلة ليه بس يا دكتور؟". انطلق بعض الحاضرين مع الدكتور خالد ليستقبلوا سعادة المحافظ. لم تفت دقيقة من خروجهم من القاعة، حتي دخل رجلا يرتدي بدلة و سيديري، يحمل كل الصفات الشكلية لشخصية القواد، قائلا بابتسامة للجميع: "السيد المحافظ لمل ييجي، هتقوموا تقفوا... هه؟". بصراحة لم ارد اثارة مشاكل حيث ان حضوري كان خدمة من الدكتورة دينا شهيب.

خيم الهدوء علي الجلسة بشكل مفاجئ، و في خلال ثواني كنت قادرا علي سمع خطوات سيادة المحافظ و هو يقترب من القاعة، يقترب اكثر، و اكثر، و اكثر، ها هو صوت حذائة علي الارضية الرخام و اضح جدا، و لسبب ما عرفت صوت حذائة علي الاخص و ليس الذين كانوا باستقبالة. فجأة فتحت ابواب القاعة ليدخل القواد و رجلان من الحاشية يتوسطهم السيد المحافظ و يخلفه الدكتور خالد. يقوم فجأة كل الحاضرين، و بالامانة كنت سأقوم انا الاخر، و لكني غيرت رأيي علي أخر لحظة. لم يكتف الحاضريين بالقيام فقط، بل بدأوا يسقفون، و السيد المحافظ يتخخللهم بتباهي متواضع.

السيد المحافظ هو رجل طويل و عريض و له هيبه، مرتسم علي وجهه جدية غريبة ذكرتني بشكلي كل صباح لحظة استيقاظي من النوم. جلس السيد المحفظ علي رأس التربيزة طبعا ثم جلس الحاضرين جميعا.
قامت سيدة للاشادة بالسيد المحافظ للاهتمام بحضورة للمؤتمر و اهتمامه بمشكلة العشوائيات، ثم قدمت الدكتور خالد ليبدأ العرض الاساسي للمؤتمر و ان اسم المؤتمر " التعامل مع العشوائيات علي ثلاث مراحل". قام الدكتور خالد بشغف يشرح الوضع و كيفية التعامل معه من خلال عرض رائع، حتي انني التهيت مع العرض و نسيت السيد المحافظ. زاغ بصري عن العرض للحظة، لاري السيد المحافظ لا يتابع العرض اطلاقا، فهو لم يكن ينظر الي الشاشة و اعتقد انه لم يكن حتي يستمع الي ما يقال. قضيت باقي العرض في مراقبة السيد المحافظ، و اقسم انه لم ينظر للشاشة و لو مره واحدة.

انهي الدكتور خالد عرضه و جائت اللحظة التي كنت انتظرها، و هي انني سأستمع لرأي السيد المحافظ عن مشكلة العشوائيات و كيفية معالجتها. اعتدل السيد المحافظ في كرسيه المميز عن باقي كراسي الحاضرين، مستهلا كلامه: " لن اتحدث عن العشوائيات...!" فطرأ في بالي مباشرة سؤالا: لن يتكلم عن العشوائيات؟؟ هل سيتكلم اذن عن المانجه العويسي الاسمعلاوي؟. خيب ظني السيد المحافظ بعدم التحدث حتي عن المانجه، بل تكلم عن ان القاعة التي كان سيتم بها المؤتمر تحت الاصلاح و ان بالاسماعيلية بدائل من القاعات لاستيعاب مؤتمرات - في تلك اللحظة اخرجت قلمي و ورقة لكتابة ما تقرأونه الأن – تكلم ايضا عن كيفية ادارة المستشفيات و عن اهمية زيارة مستشفي الاسماعيلية، ثم تحدث عن ترشيد استهلاك الطاقه و عن تجربته في الصين و عن اعجابه بالشعب الصيني في نظامهم و طرقة معيشتهم و نصح الحاضرين بالاقتداء بالصينيين في النوم المبكر و الاستيقاظ المبكر. و بالرغم من اندهاشي لمل اسمعه، الا ان الحاضريين جميعا يهزون رؤوسهم للتعبير عن ادراكهم اهمية ما يقوله سيادة المحافظ. تحدث ايضا عن التوكتوك و عن مشاكله، و انهي كلامه بدعابة خفيفة: " حد عنده توكتوك هنا؟" الجميع يضحكون.

افتتح مجال الاسئلة، فسأله احد الحاضرين عن رغيف العيش – قلت يا مسهل- ، فطمأنه السيد المحافظ و طمأننا جميعا ان نصيب الفرد في الاسماعيلية هو اربعة ارغفة في اليوم و 420 لتر مياه في اليوم. يا حلاوة. هنا فتحت ابواب القاعة ليدخل رجلان يحملان كاميرا، يبدو عليهم انهم من التليفزيون. اعتدل السيد المحافظ في كرسيه و غير تعبير وجهه من المستيقظ للتو الي وجه الفارس الجليل المحب للمصريين بادئ كلامه بشكل سينيمائي مذكرني بأداء نظيم شعراوي في فيلم النوم في العسل قائلا : "الخير كير و الحمد لله".

قام الرجل الذي يتحدث بالفصحه ليسأل هو الأخر، ففجأني بأنه بدأ كلامه بالاشاده بالمانجه الاسمعلاوي..! فطرأت التساؤلات الي ذهني: هل سمع افكاري؟ ام هل راودته نفس الفكره للسخرية من عبث الجلسة؟ هل يتكلم بجدية؟ لم اعرف الاجابة الا انه اكمل كلامه عن وش الاسماعيلية الحلو في ماتش غانا و اضاف انه اهلاوي. انهي الرجل التحدث عن المانجه و كرة القدم و بدأ في السؤال: " ماذا عن العشوائيات يا سيادة المحافظ و ما هي نظرة الدولة للعشوائيات؟" توقف قلبي من الفرحه، اخيرا، و علمت انه كان يسخر من الجلسة مثلي تماما و التفت سريعا لاستمع الي رأي السيد المحافظ الذي انتظره من اول اليوم. رجع السيد المحافظ الي الوراء و اخذ وضعا مسرحيا مجيبه: " موضوع العشوائيات ده موضوع – و بصوت عالي- شااائك"... " و اي حد يقول ان العشوائيات كتيرة في مصر يقوم بنفسة و يعمل حاجة... و يوريني بقي هيعرف يعمل ايه..." و بنبرة اعلي: " اليقول كده ده يبقي رجل (منقوص)" فبدأت في التساؤل... ما معني (رجل منقوص)؟ اهي بمعني ( راجل ناقص)؟
اهي رجل يعاني من عقدة نقص؟

تأكدت حينها انه لا يعلم اي شئ، و انهم صحوه من النوم و قالولوا قوم يا محافظ عندك جلسه و نسوا ان يقولوا له ما هو موضوع الجلسه. تأكد كلامي حين اختتم السيد المحافظ الجلسه بالاشادة بدوره في اعلاء مدينة الاسماعيلية و انجازاته الكبيرة، و لكنه اضاف محمسا قائلا: " قد يظن البعض من كلامي انني اشبه الاسماعيلية بالمدينة ال... اسمها ايه ديه.... المدينة الكاملة..." فعلق احد الحاضريين: "الفاضلة يا سيادة المحافظ" فقال: " اه... المدينة الفاضلة... لأ... لسه قدمنا شغل كتير". تصقيف.

قام السيد المحافظ، فقام الجميع و مضي في حال سبيله.

ذهبنا جميعا الي رحلة ميدانية لزيارة احدي المناطق العشوائية و التي تقع بجوار مساكن شعبية. استوقفني مشهد المساكن الشعبية للانها تقع بجانب خمسة عمارات فاخرة من نفس الشكل، محاطه بسور لفصل هذه العمارات الفاخرة عن المسان الشعبية و بالتالي لفصلها عن العشوائيات... و لكن هذه العمارات الفاخرة بها شئ غريب، فهي نفس ابعاد مباني المساكن من حيث الارتفاع و الطول و العرض، فجائت في ذهني فكرة تمنيت الا تكون صحيحة، حتي اكد لي احد مهندسين التخطيط العمراني ان فكرتي صحيحة و هي ان هذه المباني السكنية الفاخرة كانت في الاصل مساكن شعبية صممت لتأوي الفقراء و الغلابة من سكان الاسماعيلية و لكن باعتها المحافظة لمقاول بسعر ثلاثة مليون جنية للعمارة... و اضاف المهندس ان الشقة بالشئ الفيلاني...




ارتاح قلبي بما قاله السيد المحافظ علي ان الخير كثير و الحمد لله، و علي ان ليس من حقنا أن نقول ان المناطق العشوائية في زيادة مستمرة و ان لا يوجد سبب للتحدث عن العشوائيات اصلا كما بدأ كلامه بل من الواجب تحويل المساكن الشعبية الي اسكان فاخر يأوي الطبقة العليا في مجتمعنا . أشكرك سيادة المحافظ... فلقد بدأت في التفكير بتغيير مسار عملي و حياتي كناشط اجتماعي يساعد في مواجهة الفقر في مصر، الي تاجر مانجه عويسي فص اسمعلاوي من أم 35 جنيه الكيلو.

Sunday, November 1, 2009

El Tahrir Square: A Multi Layered History Urban Space




The story of downtown Cairo's transformation is complex. From the origins of the modern city district to its ongoing transformations, downtown has reflected the city's social cultural and economic shifts. These transformations came in many forms including the general urban expansion of highways through the center, the use and reuse of early twentieth century buildings, the moving in and out of institutions such as Hilton hotel, the American university and the Egyptian museum and finally the redefinition of the public space in the general Cairene context. In this paper I have listed and analyzed these moments to transition and their effect on the urban landscape of el Tahrir square and its cultural, social and historical significance in the making of a nostalgically driven architectural image today.


Along through the history of Cairo, squares and urban open spaces played a very important role in gathering the inhabitants for events, ceremonies and protests. "The Tahrir Square" is one of the most important squares in Cairo that played that role very well till today, and as el Ahram weekly once wrote about el Tahrir Square: "Tahrir Square is not only the hub of Cairo, it is home to some of the city's most important buildings and a constant headline-maker in the local press. Whatever happens in Tahrir immediately becomes a national concern." And as Samir Raafat said in the Cairo times "Midan al-Tahrir cannot sit still. Whether reflecting the city's moods or the leadership's political agenda, the nation's most important plaza has gone from faux Champs de Mars to Stalinesque esplanade. Whenever a new regime feels the nation's capital needs a new look, the Midan has been the place to start."

Ismailiya square (el Tahrir square now) was and still is the center of central Cairo. From it the first bridge crossed the Nile and the palace housing the British headquarter stood. Samir Raafat has referred to is as a "faux champ de mars." a forced analogy to continue the "tradition" of linking Ismail's Cairo with Paris in anyway possible. In fact the square was not a faux of anything; it was a very real Ismailiyya square. The square acted as a southern gateway to downtown and a pivotal point in the transition westward across the Kasr el Nil bridge to Cairo's future development and expansions. The abundance of things named Ismail in and around the square made it an easy target for change that would announce the arrival of a new era.

El Tahrir early establishment and planning


I. Islamic Era


Once, the highly developed square was a patch of silt, part of the Nile's bed. In the 16th and 17th centuries the Nile shrank eastwards, uncovering land which was to become the Qasr Al-Aini area, Munira, Garden City, and Tahrir Square. In those days, however, the area was known as Al-Louq. The first developments on the new land were far from glamorous. At the beginning of the last century, the Cairo tanneries were moved from Hawsh Al-Sharqawi (south of Midan Bab Al-Khalq) to the Louq area because of their bad smell. In 1865, they were moved to an area near Fustat, where they have remained ever since. (Center of the centers, el Ahram weekly, sept 1999 issue 445). Fig 1.1

Until the time of Al-Nasser Mohamed Ibn Qalawun, who developed the area into a garden reputed to have included all sorts of fruits and flowers, many of which were brought in from the Levant. Meanwhile, a certain Emir Tussun became an important political figure, prompting the sultan to give him a part of this garden. Tussun established a stable there, on the banks of the Nile. The stables won the place its name: Zaribat Tussun. After thriving for a time under Al-Nasser, the area became a quagmire of swamps and lakes interspersed with gardens.


II. Khedive Era


The next saviour of the site was Ali Mubarak under Ismail Pasha (1863-1879). Ismail was the patron of a comprehensive project to develop the city of Cairo and Mubarak was his right-hand man in the task. The latter earmarked an area of 359 feddans for major development and rehabilitation -- an area originally known as the Ismailia quarter, today the downtown area. (Where the Streets Have No Name, Egypt today magazine, april 2005)


The khedive wanted to make Cairo a piece of Paris. These photos shows the relation between el Tahrir square in Cairo and Charles de Gaulle etoil square in Paris

Streets were planned in straight lines at right angles in most cases and squares were made. (fig 1.2). On both sides of the streets were pedestrian walkways, and the middle of the street was for cars and animals. So it was inhabited by princes and great people. It became -- and remains -- the navel of the city and is the site of the most important services whether they be government, companies, banks or commercial stores. Although Ismail is always credited with the creation of Midan Al-Ismailia, Said Pasha before him oversaw developments that fed into the creation of the square. In fact, the first landmark in the history of what is known today as Tahrir began with the Qasr Al-Nil Barracks (which stood where the Nile Hilton stands today) set up in the reign of Khedive Said (1854-1863). The barracks also served as the Ministry of War and drew people's attention to the area west of Cairo, setting the pattern for developments that were introduced by Ismail Pasha later on. The British took over the barracks when they took over Egypt, and the red buildings were to become a hated symbol of occupation. Eventually Egypt was to rid itself of the British and in the place of the barracks; the Arab League and the Nile Hilton hotel were built. (Streets and Midans by el Sayed Mohammed)



The Modern Transformation


"once the rather exclusive domain of the colonial foreigners and franc phonic Egyptian elite, this zone has obviously undergone a dramatic transformation since the revolution of 1952" Janet abo Lughod
And in the novel by Alaa el Aswany "The Yacoubian Building" it is centered on a building which stands as a symbol of beautiful times, a piece of urban iconography, whose cultural contect has shifted to the in bearable present. It sees the present as having lost something which was alive in the past, making the past more attractive.
The modern transformations of el Tahrir square viewed two major turning points; the Nasser's era and the notion of modernity, and the Sadat era and the notion of infitah:



I. The First Turning Point (Nasser 1952)


Nasser's first set of alterations for Cairo included the remaining of downtown streets and squares, this included Ismail square where the barracks and the museum were located. The new square would be called Midan el Tahrir (liberation square) and Kasr el Nil barracks building was torn down in 1952 to figuratively liberate the square of its occupation (el Musawwar magazine 1947). The building could have remained and been reused as was the fate of many downtown buildings, however the choice to remove the building was a necessary symbolic act (Maria Golia, city of sand, 2004). And Ismail once quickly built his modern city, Nasser quickly constructed concrete blocks his new ministries, national enterprise and civil servants. The fact of these buildings would soon showcase an alliance with the east, the USSR whose notorious soviet modernist architecture was spread as far as its economics arm reached. The Ussr's willingness to fund Nasser's large scale project as the Aswan high dam would mark the new beginning for the facades of Cairo. Prior to this alliance downtown was already blessed with soviet inspired block, The Mogamma. (Facades of modernity, Mohamed el Shahed, 2005)



The Mogamma



The notorious fifteen-story Mogamma was part of a plan to redevelop Ismailiyya sq under king Farouk. Although the building is associated in the Egyptian collective memory as a vestige of Nasser era bureaucracy. It was actually opened in 1951 immediately before the revolution. The building was described by its architect Kamal Ismail to be a "simplified form of the Islamic style" and was designed to house "a large number of bureaucratic functions… under one roof, including many carried out ministries of interior and education, as well as the new Cairo municipality itself." (Fatma Farrag, www.weekly.ahram.org.eg/2005/764/feature.htm).



The Nile Hilton



Nasser opened the zone of Tahrir square for modern hotels to develop along the east bank of the Nile. The proximity to the museum and the famed downtown made the southern tip of the district a prime location for tourist accommodations. The Semiramis, le meridian, Sheraton and Hilton quickly took advantage of the opportunity to establish new business in the center of the world's oldest tourist destination and birth place of western civilization. The Hilton on Tahrir square was Nasser's attempt at attracting foreign currency, tourism and advertising an interest in capitalism. The hotel opened in February 1959 and "the modern form of the structure was the materialization of the modern social practices that it housed. The building rendered public certain aspects of Nasser's new Egypt. It monumentalized Egypt's ambition to acquire international political status through modernization" (Wharton. Cited in "facades of modernity by Mohamed el Shahed, 2005). The architecture of the hotel and its white façade is a twelve-story high blank billboard on Tahrir showcasing Nasser's vision for the city.


The Nile Hilton was a new façade associated with a new era' however, what was behind the façade was a familiar institution: a social space for the rich and powerful in Cairo akin to the old shepherd's hotel. The functional façade of the hotel with its equally sized room balconies and the exposed stairs, three on each side of the slab. Zigzagging up its side appears to be a new departure from the classical architecture of the museum next door or even the recently opened Mogamma. Although the building was a private enterprise accessible to a few, its symbolism on the site of the old barracks and its modern contemporary image was seen by all Egyptians who flood the square. The building thus as a double-edged tool for Nasser, signifying a degree of openness to the west marking a new beginning to locals with a clear architectural symbol, finally wradicating to ghost of British occupation on the site.


The Results of the First Turning Point

After the revolution was fully effected, the cosmopolitan ethnically non Egyptians population of downtown along 4000 wealthy Egyptian families began their exodus from the city. Nasser would officially rid the city of its outsiders residents and confiscate their property in the name of revolution. In the immediate months after the revolution, the once prestigious but now abandoned downtown flates, buildings and shops were quickly taken over by the government companies, revolutionary military personnel anf their families, a significant transformation in the socio-cultural make up of the district. (Beattie, cited in "facades of modernity by Mohamed el Shahed, 2005 Besides the shifting demographic of the area and the transformation of downtown roofs into squatter settelemnts for the poor, the core of downtown will be replaced by taller apartment blocks. The southern end of downtown around the ismailiyya suare is where dramatic Nasser era change will take place in this part of the city. (Facades of modernity, Mohamed el Shahed, 2005)

Another vision by Andre Raymond in his book Cairo which is not too far from Mohamed el Shahed's vision, where he stated that "The view of downtown as a distinctly different district from its surrounding has been dissolved and blurred as it deteriorated and its surroundings modernized in up-dated style. Most importantly, the previously European associated customs and behaviors have been so absorbed into the popular psyche of the Egyptian middle class which inhabits the city in all directions around downtown. Downtown no longer was the stage of certain behaviors or codes of dress, for better or worst, it has lost any signs of alienation and it has been fully integrated. Greater Cairo has lost its center, and in the coming decades as the city expands into the desert in government planned cities such as Nasr city, Cairo will be multi-center fragmented city with zones catering to three economically divided social groups: lower strata, intermediate strata of Cairo's social space. By the second half of the twentieth century downtown's density was slightly declining sa residents left it and it increasingly was becoming lower class. Cairo new modern, luxury quarters in the 1960s were diffused in Zamalek or Dokky while the primary streets of downtown falling into disrepair are more active then ever before with ordinary goods replacing luxury items in stores" (Andre Raymond. Cairo, Harvard university press 2000).



I. The Second Turning Point (Sadat 1970)

In the 1970s with Sadat's Infitah policy, downtown buildings witnessed their worst deterioration. By the mid-1970s development has ceased to exist in downtown for over thirty years with major catastrophic events such as Black Saturday and the migration of residents by 1956, the central district grew increasingly popular with bargain shoppers and professionals establishing more businesses in the upper floors of downtown buildings transforming the area into a fully commercial zone that is swarming with activity during the day and abandoned by night. Except for the occasional news about razing of belle époque buildings to be replaced by multi-level garage structures or high-rise office blocks, the area was for the greater part of the 70s, 80s and 90s forgotten by the general public. The recent revival of interest in the old central so-called-European district of downtown is due to a new phase of Cairene identity-making, the search for a counter balance to the present fragmented city with its multiple manifestations serving diverse social and economic segments of the population that do not share a city center.



The Results of the Second Turning Point


Downtown Cairo is contested space, between the rich and the poor, government agencies and private interests, pedestrians and motor traffic, streets vendors and shopkeepers and most importantly between promoters of visual rehabilitation and promoters of tactile rehabilitation. Downtown is thus in the middle of multi faceted conflict between competing interests all of whom aim at optimizing their advantages. The larger trend of commercial and economic decentralization that Cairo is witnessing has shifted the primary node of commercial activity to scattered points in the city. Downtown is also loosing its role as a cultural node for the city with the moving of the Egyptian museum. the American university in Cairo also left its urban campus in the contested space of downtown Cairo for a garden campus on the periphery. The American university expansion is another missed opportunity that could have transformed downtown Cairo into vibrant, expansive urban injecting money and resources into the center.
Downtown thus transformed from an urban space conveying aesthetic beauty to merely a domain for circulation. (Krampen, 1979. cited in "facades of modernity by Mohamed el Shahed, 2005) the belle époque facades of downtown were embellished with multi-story signs and billboards the respond to the scale of the speedway.





El Tahrir physical urban development

El Tahrir square as previously stated Witnessed several historical changes, it also witnessed a lot of urban changes, especially in the garden next to it. After the Egyptian Museum was built by August Mariette, the streets weren't paved and the ground was just made of dust. Then after it was paved, a Granite base was placed in the middle of the circular square and it was suppose to hold a statue for Ismail Pasha, where it was going to act as a major landmark in the center of Cairo. Another landmark was built in the late 60s which is a huge circular pedestrian bridge around the square, where it changed the perception to the urban space; this bridge was removed in the late 70s

The square itself was designed to be a huge round about, where the garden next to it was a recreational area where lots of people used it very well around the fountain and modern structures. What was so unique about this garden is that the urban space is not enclosed well, but in this huge space the garden gave the chance to let the user perceive all the surrounding buildings very well. And also environmentally it used to balance with the smoke coming from the traffic around it. A change of use occurred in the garden in the mid 80s where it turned into a huge parking lot for the tourists buses in front of the museum. Now days the government is working on changing this place to an underground parking and revive the garden again over the parking to revitalize this space one more time.


El Tahrir Life and People

I. The Relation between the Naming "Leberation" and the Behavior





El Tahrir square is known till now as the political square in Cairo, still demonstrations are held there, but the problem is that there is no place for demonstrations so its always a huge traffic jam especially that el Tahrir is one of the main traffic round about in Cairo and affects on other areas when it is crowded. But does the name still affect? And is it really where people go there to practice their liberty?


II. Billboards on over the Buildings






Billboards above the buildings surrounding the square, where it's the most expensive spot in Cairo. But the problem here is that these advertisements became more dominant then the buildings where the buildings are one of the most obvious features around the square because of their unique Architecture. So do el Tahrir's Users perceive the building or the billboard?



III. El Tahrir as a Cosmopolitan square






A very important feature which is the vitality of the space as in el Tahrir square contains a lot of functions and uses. This vitality results different users, where el Tahrir square contains all levels of people from every where and different cultures, where that's because of the Mogamma that serves Egyptians coming from other cities to finish their governmental papers. The museum and the Nile Hilton affects as well the vitality where the tourists and foreign people appear, and in a result of that lots of bazaars are opened to serve them. The American University where the neo liberalism community as stated in Diane Singerman "Cairo Cosmopolitan" where it's a mixed between Egyptians and foreign attitudes.
So will it still have these users after the moving of the Mogamma the museum and the university?


Conclusion
While doing a research in el Darb el Ahmar, we were able to sit with people and have a long chat and interviews, while in the Tahrir square, it was so hard because everyone is running and trying to catch something, but luckily one of the passers (Mr. Mahmud Hafez, a lawyer) gave me a minute to ask him "what do you think about el Tahrir Square now days and old ones??" and he answered: " it's beginning to be a pass by space, nobody's doing anything in the square itself, everybody is coming from Abd el Moneim square going to el Kasr el Einy street or from Zamalek to downtown… they are all passing by el Tahrir square… but it's not really because they want to come here… it doesn't belong to anyone…"





References:

- - The case of Cairo, Egypt by David Sim Contribution by Marion Sejoume and Monika El Shorbagi
- - Center of the centers, el Ahram weekly, sept. 1999 issue 445
- - Streets and Midans by el Sayed Mohammed
- - Where the Streets Have No Name, Egypt today magazine, april 2005
- - The expanding Metropolis Copying with the Urban Growth of Cairo, Agha Khan conference
- - Cairo Cosmopolitan by Diane Singer man
- - Facades of modernity, Mohamed el Shahed, 2005
- - City of the Sand by Maria Golia 2004
- - Cairo by Andre Raymond 2000
- - 1001 years of city victorious by Janet abo Lughd 1971
- - Fatma Farrag, www.weekly.ahram.org.eg/2005/764/feature.htm

Saturday, October 31, 2009

Cairo's Qahwa: The Active Contributor to the City's Texture.




Greater Cairo is studded with the monuments of its 5,000 years of history ranging from the Pharaonic in Sakkara, Giza and Heliopolis, to the Christian and Islamic heritage in Fustat and Islamic Cairo to the remains of Ottoman rule in the Citadel. With the exception of the mosques, most of these are no longer functioning and are under the management of the Ministry of Culture and require a few LE to enter. But there are still vestiges of an era in Cairo’s past that are still functioning like traditions, ethics and behaviors, where these aspects were reflected on physical spaces. One of these spaces is the coffee house or "el qahwa". Such place is present in all cultures and through all ages, yet they take different forms. As a spatial representation of communities, the café space changes constantly in the tune with their own journey through time. The changes also follows communities as they move around, settling away from home which they attempt to recreate among the new surrounding.


There is little doubt that the old-school street café, or qahwa, holds immense appeal. Once you grow accustomed to a qahwa, it becomes yours. At once inside and outside, Cairo's best qahwas are straightforward, unpretentious and yet full of history. Alone or accompanied, your presence is diluted into the street, and however rested you are, still you remain an active contributor to the city's texture. As the cup of coffee is the last item in the Qahwa's importance menu… where more prominent is the long list of their offering are social and intellectual interactions, retreat and sanctuary, entertainment and field of political discussions…


The origin of the word Qahwa

The journey started in the 15th centaury, where The beverage known as qahwa — a term
formerly applied to wine — and ultimately, to Europeans, as "The Wine of Islam." It became popular among the Sufis to boil up the grounds and drink the brew to help them stay awake during their night dhikr. (Roasting the beans was a later improvement developed by the Persians. By way of pilgrims, traders, students and travelers, coffee spread throughout the Islamic world. Al-Azhar became an early center of coffee-drinking, and a certain amount of ceremony began to surround it. One 16th century writer describes dervish meetings in Cairo:
"They drank coffee every Monday and Friday eve, putting it in a large vessel made of red clay. Their leader ladled it out with a small dipper and gave it to them to drink, passing it to the right, while they recited one of their usual formulas, mostly "La illaha il'Allah..."
Ibn abd el Ghaffar

“Qahwa”: was a word in common use before coffee itself was known: it has a long pedigree as one of the epithets of wine. The Arabic root q-h-w/y denotes the idea of making something repugnant, or lessening one’s desire for something. According to one medieval Arab lexicographer, qahwa is “wine, so named because it puts the drinker off his food; that is to say, it removes his appetite [for it].” The application of this term to coffee was a simple step: just as wine removes one’s desire for food, so coffee removes one’s desire for sleep.”

The History of Qahwa

I: Islamic Era

Throughout the first few centuries of its history in the Islamic world, coffee's popularity
engendered great controversy. Many were suspicious of the effects of caffeine and the gatherings in which it was consumed — they seemed debauched to some and subversive to others. Coffeehouses competed with mosques for attendance, and as unsupervised gathering places for wits and learned men, provided spawning grounds for sedition. The wags of Istanbul jokingly called the coffeehouses mekteb-i 'irfan, "schools of knowledge." Efforts were launched, and persisted for at least a hundred years, to declare coffee an intoxicant forbidden by Islamic law:
According to hadith attributed to Muhammad by the three schools that opposed alcohol in any form is: “Every intoxicant is khamr and every intoxicant is forbidden.”
The coffee was forbidden and became illegal in all Egypt for four reasons:


  1. Coffee was thought in some way physically or chemically so constituted as to make its consumption a violation of Islamic law, either because it was intoxicating or physically harmful.

  2. Coffee was rejected by the ultrapious simply because it was an innovation, bid’a.

  3. The political activities that became an important part of the sociaal life of the coffeehouse grew increasingly alarming to the governmental elite.

  4. The patrons of the coffeehouse indulged in a variety of improper pastimes, ranging from gambling to involvement in irregular and criminally unorthodox sexual situations.

And during Ramadan in 1539 CE Cairo's coffeehouses were raided and closed.
h

The moralists fought a losing battle, for they were opposed by well-educated coffee-drinkers from the highest ranks of the religious and political hierarchy who did not look fondly upon innovative legal prohibitions. The "tavern without wine" offered a respectable gathering place for men to socialize and entertain away from home. Business was especially brisk during Ramadan, when proprietors made extra efforts to draw crowds with storytellers and puppet shows. In the 16th century the coffee houses were reopened again.
According to Lane, the coffeehouses of Cairo were frequented by “the lower orders.” Alexander Russell said that the “vulgar” went to the Aleppo coffeehouses. Dufour, writing about Istanbul, says that all but the “very high” come to the coffeehouse.” D’Ohsson says that among those who flocked to the Istanbul coffeehouses were “beys, nobles, officers, teachers, judges and other people of the law.”


The coffee houses in Cairo were quiet simple, it usually had an arcade façade where people used to sit on wooden or stone benches with their back to the wall. Inside, other benches skirted along two or three sides of the coffee house. The floor was usually covered by rags and palm leaves or fabric. ( M. abo Tera( Hookahs and tobaccos were introduced to the qahwa at this time where A Turkish traveler in Ottoman Cairo wrote, in the late sixteenth century:“coffee-houses of Egypt are filled mostly with dissolute persons and opium-eaters.” Also musicians and belly dancers started to perform in the qahwas for entertainment.



II. Khedive era

Muhammad ‘Ali, in Cairo in the nineteenth century, found a better use for coffeehouses: he
allowed them to remain open and sent spies to overhear the plots as they were hatched. “One wishing to hear the latest news—or, more likely, the freshest rumors—needed only to station himself in the coffeehouse for a short time.” Edward Lane. Then Khedive Ismail introduced new cafes in Cairo after that which they had a new setting of French influences, as Groppi and Café Rich, where they served the upper class and the middle and lower classes kept using the traditional Qahwa.



Groppi was a popular café brand in the first half of the 20th century. The first branch opened in 1909 in the newly built downtown; the district planned to resemble European cities. The second branch was designed by Italian architect Guiseppe Mazza and opened in 1924, also in downtown Cairo. Its design is a good example of this genre of colonial cafes; there is a café room, a restaurant, a ballroom and the routenda, a round hall for the taking of tea and dance parties, activities that were solo preserve of the exposed classes. On the other hand was café rich which it started and remained till now the cultural intellectual café. Café Riche has played its part in political history as a place of intrigue and conspiracy. According to the historian Abdel Rahman El Rafei, the leaders of the 1919 Revolution used the café as a meeting place to plan their strategy to oust the British once and for all. It used to has several regular guests as Youssef wahby, Naguib Mahfouz, Amal Donkol, Twfik el Hakim, Mohammed Slamawy and more.. and even all their photos are in there to give the notion of authenticity.


Mean while in the traditional qahwa and before the appearance of the theaters and cinemas all around Cairo, the traditional qahwa played a very important role in art and music, where the qahwa was the secret word for musicians and singers where it was a way to meet together. As Sayed Darwish met Salama Hegazy for the first time in a traditional qahwa in 1911.
The qahwa remained nearly exactly the same as the very old one, just some furniture was changed but the behavior and setting was nearly the same. Simple wooden chairs replaced the benches with the name of the carpenter often engraved on the back, tables were smaller with tall metal legs and metal sheet top that is suitable for drinks, bigger wooden tables for board games. And Radios were introduced to the qahwa.




III. The Modern Era

These two genres of cafes (Groppi and Rich) coexisted side by side until the social mood changed
and became less stable following the political upheavals in the 1950s. after the socialist revolution in 1952, aristocrats were stripped of their titles and land. Places that used to belong to the upper classes, were viewed as a symbol of rotten aristocracy. As a result of this, such cafes and their cultures slipped into obscurity in the 1960s, while the other qahwas kept running without harm. But café rich wasn't harmed as well as its users and regulars considered the café is their home. The middle class gradually lost its popularity in 1970s with the café increasingly perceived as an unclean place for the unemployed, giving way to civilized public spaces of social and sporting clubs.




This continued till the 1990s and despite growing population, new café's barely opened to the extent that the writer Gamal el Gheitany expressed his belief that cafes and their culture were heading towords extinction. But luckily this did not happened where starting from the 1990s the traditional qahwa started to introduce television where the middle class returned back to qahwa to watch football matches. And also in the mid 1990s, a new generation of cafes for the upper class emerged. This new breed of café looks westernized, sounds westernized and even serve western drinks and food.




The New Generation of Cafes

These new generation cafes are also detached from the street and public activity hiding away
from them; this is usually achieved by building a wall or plantation fence or being inside a building. It is also thematic with most of the new cafes use the design as a striking attraction for the users, where the designs differ between each café and the other, one is modern cubism, the other is Mediterranean or Latin, and even some designs are reflecting old Cairo and Nubian life. Such themes and designs are interesting as they snatched out of their context and represented as an exotic atmosphere. And as Anouk de Koning said in Cairo Cosmopolitan:
"These upscale coffee houses changed the urban fabric of affluent neighborhoods; enjoying a café latte or a ceasar salade in one of these coffee shops has become part of the semidaily routine of many young and relatively affluent Cairenes."
The new generation of coffee shops was able to gather girls from their houses and the club, where before they did not have any place else to go after work, as in the traditional qahwa the male is dominant.



Egyptian Cafes Abroad

There is a lot of middle eastern cafes abroad, especially London, which has several Egyptian cafes. This Egyptian character of the café is not reflected in its design. Apart from the outdoor areas orientation outwords and the slightly dense interior the café appears quiet English. In fact the café's English patron choosing from the menu during the day are inaware of its night life, simply because there is nothing in the café to reveal it. The café has a modern clean look, a polish waitress in the daytime, a Panini grill and clear window before counter displaying food to choose from elements of an average café at lunch time in London. All of these features remain at night, fitting despite the changed environment. Once again the core of the café lies in the people's behavior within the space with anything else only a marginal trapping (M. Abo Tera) English people spend less then 30 minutes to take a coffee and a muffin, but Egyptian go to the café by 6 pm to spend the whole night there mingling between all tables as they all know each others.





Intangible Conservation

After giving a story of the qahwa in cairo and how did it start and then the different kinds of it till the new generation that is totally different from any of the previous, Edward Lane asked a question: "“If we grant that the tavern provided the most convenient model for those wishing to introduce coffee to the public at large, why then would people continue to frequent such shops once they became familiar with the methods of preparation?”




Which that exactly the answer: Socializing, where along through the history of Cairo we conserved socializing through the qahwa, not for the beverage.

Authenticity

The physical feature and culture of the café is not as it used to be anymore, televisions displaying "Melody channel", very few cultural cafes, no music played… all that affect the setting of the qahwa, also the new generation cafes and the western modern influences affected the culture itself of the qahwa, where all new qahwas are trying to make the design and menus as western ones.
el Fishawy café in el Hussein el Fishawy café in Sharm el Sheikh

Also the banners of the café names are getting to be all in English where it wasn't that way before.



Also some of the old cafés tried to revive the old cultures as café rich which putting all the regular users photos from writers, artists and intellects. In café rich as well the waiters still wear the same unform they used to wear from the day it was opened. Another feature being revived in fishawy as some people playing music go there to sing for money and some to be a first step to be famous.


References

-Diane Singerman, Cairo Cosmopolitan 2005
- Edward Lane, Traditions of the Modern Egyptians between 1833 and 1835
- Ulla Heise, Coffee and Coffeehouses, 1973
- Serene Assir, Al-Ahram Weekly Living Restaurant review Not quite, 30 August - 5 September 2007, issue no.860
- Mohammed Abo Tera, the Qhwa: A Culture Apart, Magaz Magazine, May 2008, issue no.1
- Coffee the wine of Islam, http://www.superluminal.com/cookbook/essay_coffee.html
- دور المقاهي في النهضه الفنية العربية, مدونات المكتوب, مارس 2008
- كافيه ريش الثقافي :مقهى يدافع عن ذاكرة أمة-www_aljazeeratalk_net-forum-upload-2152-1190880136_jpg.mht
-